Licensed Professional Engineers
A newsletter dedicated to keeping attorneys informed of the technical side of product liability cases.
Issue 53: Vol. 1 February/March 2013
© 2013 M.A.S.E. LLC
( 479) 549-4860
FORENSIC CLUES # 53 - "Office Chair Testing Criteria" by John L. Ryan
We are often contacted regarding various types of chair accidents, including chair collapse and tipping accidents. Some of these accidents can be due to connection failures such as bolt, screw, or weld failure, or a manufacturing or material defect. Many chair accidents however are due to design flaws that result in chair instability, catastrophic structural failure, or component failure. Our standard protocol in these cases is to test an exemplar chair per industry standards, which in this case is ANSI/BIFMA X5.1. This issue of Clues will examine some of the different criteria that office chairs must pass in order to be compliant with this voluntary standard.
The standard groups office chairs into one of three types. Type 1 includes tilting chairs where the seat and backrest both tilt rearward together.
Figure 1: Type 1 Tilting Office Chair
Type 2 chairs are fixed seat angle chairs that have a tilting backrest. Type 3 chairs are fixed seat angle and fixed backrests chairs, whether on rollers or with fixed legs.
Chair Testing Criteria
Backrest Strength Test
This test is designed to test the ability of a chair to withstand forces and stresses placed on it from the chair occupant leaning backwards against the backrest. This is the test to perform on chairs involved in accidents where the backrest tilted backwards and caused harm to the occupant.
Failures that result in the backrest tilting reward In this test, for Type 1 chairs, the base of the chair is constrained, and a load of 200 pounds is applied to the backrest at about 16 inches above the seat. The load is applied using a distribution device, preferably one that conforms to the shape of the seat, approximately 12 inches x 3.5 inches x 0.5 inches. There must be no loss of serviceability to the chair after holding the load for one minute. A proof load of 300 pounds is then applied in the same manner, with loss of serviceability being allowed as long as there is no significant reduction in the structural integrity of the chair. For type 2 and 3 chairs, chairs with fixed seat angles, the test is similar, only with a lower load of 150 pounds and 250 pounds for the functional load and proof load, respectively.
This test is to ensure that the base of a pedestal chair can withstand loads that will be applied to the chair, including a factor of safety for dynamic loading that occurs when someone drops into the chair as opposed to slowly lowering into it. If an accident results in a broken chair base, this test will help determine if there is a design flaw that resulted in the failure. To perform this test, all seating components are removed from the base including casters. A force of 2500 pounds is applied to the center of chair base for one minute. Acceptance criteria is that no significant loss of structural integrity will occur after removal of the load.
Drop tests are performed to insure the ability of a chair to withstand heavy impact forces. In this test a 225 pound load consisting of a bag with sand is raised six inches above the seat and released. No loss of serviceability can occur with this load. A proof load of 300 pounds is then dropped onto the seat, where no significant loss of structural integrity.
Many chair accidents involve a chair tipping over resulting in injuries to the occupant. It is imperative in these accident cases to determine if a chair meets stability requirements. One test is the Stability Test found in the ANSI/BIFMA X5.1 standard. If a chair cannot meet the criteria in this test, it could be found to be unreasonably dangerous, and the cause of the accident.
Many chairs have various adjustments to them. Stability tests should be performed with the test in the least stable position to determine standard compliance. The least stable position of a chair may include raising the seat and backrest height, reducing the tilt mechanism tension to its minimum, positioning the seat as far to the rear as possible, and positioning the least stable position of casters which would be with the casters rotated inward such that the footprint of the chair is minimized.
A 173 pound weight is placed on the center of the seat of the chair, and the chair prevented from sliding by affixing 1/2 inch blocks to the test platform. These blocks should not interfere with the ability of the chair to tip. A rearward force is then applied to the backrest of the chair at a position near the top of the test weight in the seat. The force is increased until the front legs or wheels begin to lift off of the test platform. In order to meet standard criteria, the chair should be able to withstand 20 pounds of force for chairs that are Type 1 or Type 2. Type 3 chairs should be able to withstand 35 pounds.
Typically forward chair stability is not as big of an issues as rearward. There are forward chair stability requirements that chairs can be tested to if an accident of this type occurs. Additional stability testing criteria may be needed to insure that the chair design is adequate.
Leg Strength Test
Chair legs often fail, resulting in the collapse of the chair and the occupant being thrown to the ground. The leg strength test can determine if a chair has adequate strength and bracing to safely accommodate the forces that are encountered in daily use. The leg strength test involves loading a leg of a chair at the weakest point of the leg. A load of 75 pounds is applied to the end of each chair leg for one minute, with a proof load of 125 pounds for one minute. The chair is loaded in the front to rear or rear to front direction. Another part of this test involves placing a 75 pound and 115 pound load to the side of the chair legs.
Other Test Criteria
There are numerous other test criteria that may be applicable to chair failures, including cyclical tests on the swivel of a chair, the tilt mechanism, the backrest, chair base, arms, and other components.
I Have a Client with Injuries from a Chair Failure - what do I do?
Like most accidents involving potentially defective products, it is important to preserve the evidence of the chair involved in the incident. This may not always be possible since some time typically has passed by the time an accident victim seeks an attorney. The chair is likely to be owned by a third party, who may or may not be helpful. Take whatever steps necessary to have the chair preserved. The next step is to get some photographs of the subject chair, particularly of the damage to the chair, to us at email@example.com. We will take a look at the damage and let you know what the next step should be. If the chair is still available, much information can be found out by an inspection of the chair. There may be manufacturing or material defects that led to the chair failure. Testing of an exemplar per chair standards discussed in this Clues is the next step to establish a design defect that caused the accident.
What We Can Do For You
Provide mechanical engineering expertise for your product liability case
Help you decide on whether to take a case—we’ll give you a free, no obligation case assessment just call us at (479) 549-4860
Perform detailed and thorough engineering analysis of products involved in accidents
Communicate technical information effectively
Design solutions to product hazards that are left unguarded
Please call us to discuss any questions you have about unsafe products. (479) 549-4860
© 2013 Mechanical and Safety Engineering
Mechanical and Safety Engineering LLC (MASE)
P.O. Box 6007
Springdale , AR 72766